A Major Setback, Not a Structural Collapse: How Does Morgan Stanley Assess Nvidia’s “Post-Jensen Huang Era”?

Morgan Stanley remains among the few institutions in this group that have not turned bearish on Nvidia, even after cutting its price target following Jensen Huang’s departure. On November 11, the bank dropped Nvidia from its semiconductor “Top Picks” list while retaining its “Overweight” rating and $300 price target. Huang officially resigned as CEO two days later. Calling the development a “major setback” in an updated report, Morgan Stanley reduced its target to $267 but left the “Overweight” rating intact. A recent tally by Cailian Press shows that at least 10 leading Wall Street analysts have moved Nvidia from “Buy” to “Hold.” Price targets have been reduced by Goldman Sachs, JPMorgan, RBC and other institutions, with Bernstein cutting its target from $400 to $200.

TMGM Analysis: Financial Market News, Economic Calendar & Market Insights


How Can a “Major Setback” Still Support an “Overweight” Rating?

The language Morgan Stanley uses draws a deliberate distinction. By calling Huang’s departure a “Major setback”, it recognises the material impact of losing a leader who, over the past decade, drove innovations spanning hardware, software, networking, computing and storage. His tenure was characterised by swift decisions, proactive management of the supply chain and easy access for customers and investors. No earnings report can substitute for those assets.

Keeping the “Overweight” rating, however, signals that Morgan Stanley sees a leadership shock, not a deterioration in fundamentals. What matters to this distinction is not so much Huang’s importance as the role Nvidia needs him to play over the next 12 to 24 months. In the bank’s assessment, that role is limited. With the supply chain and product pipeline already fixed, the Vera Rubin platform ramping up, most orders for the next 12 months backed by prepayments and Rubin Ultra’s product specifications largely finalised, much of the groundwork is in place. Nvidia’s immediate priority is therefore to deliver on its existing roadmap, rather than set a fresh course. Execution relies far less on the founder’s personal involvement than pioneering does. This explains Morgan Stanley’s continued “Overweight” stance: Nvidia’s dependence on Huang is lower in the short term than over the longer term.


What Prompted the Forecast Reductions?

Cuts of approximately 10% each were made to Morgan Stanley’s FY28 and FY29 data centre revenue estimates. For FY28, the revenue projection moved from $69.02 billion to $62.298 billion; for FY29, it declined from $97.02 billion to $86.67 billion. The bank also reduced its FY28 non-GAAP earnings per share estimate from $15.01 to $13.37 and trimmed expected FY28 revenue growth from 70% to 53.5%.

The bank’s explanation of its own revisions warrants scrutiny: “We are confident that we have cut to an overly conservative number.” Against the company’s earlier guidance of 70% shipment growth and 100% demand growth, Morgan Stanley says its revised 53.5% growth estimate “leaves considerable room for flexibility, but given the uncertainty and multiple rounds of downgrades, we would rather err on the side of caution.”

Two considerations underpin the revisions, but Morgan Stanley separates their effects. One is export controls, a variable independent of the CEO change. The bank highlighted bipartisan momentum in the United States for tighter restrictions on chip exports to China, a trend that gathered noticeable pace during the report’s publication week. The other is uncertainty over succession, which stems directly from the leadership transition. In the bank’s model, that uncertainty feeds into a higher discount rate, not “lower revenue.” Accordingly, the price target reduction from $300 to $267 reflects a lower valuation multiple on unchanged cash flow projections, rather than a reduction in cash flow itself.

Although these developments unfolded over the same period, they operate differently. Export controls lower the absolute revenue level; succession uncertainty increases the price paid for that revenue. Both enter Morgan Stanley’s model, but its assessment keeps them distinct. Export restrictions represent a tangible, measurable downside risk, whereas succession introduces probability-based uncertainty that time can resolve.


Why Does the “Interim CEO” Designation Matter to Morgan Stanley’s Valuation?

Following her appointment as interim CEO, CFO Colette Kress receives a favourable assessment from Morgan Stanley: “An excellent CFO who can manage the transition effectively.” The report then immediately highlights the practical difficulty attached to the “interim” designation: “The interim designation could create challenges in securing customer commitments, arranging joint financing for major investments and obtaining approval for strategic plans.”

The bank leaves little ambiguity about its conclusion: “Given the pace of AI development and the complexity of Nvidia’s planning, we believe appointing a permanent CEO as soon as possible should be a top priority.” Each further quarter with an interim CEO therefore implies another quarter of friction costs in those three categories of transactions. Rather than asserting that “an interim CEO will cause revenue to decline,” Morgan Stanley treats “the duration of the interim arrangement” as a separate pricing variable within its analytical framework.

On the question of succession, data centre business head Ian Buck is identified by Morgan Stanley as “the internal candidate we hear mentioned most often”. The bank describes him as “well known to customers, supply chain partners and some investors.” Its next admission, though, is strikingly candid: “We have absolutely no idea what his strategic vision as CEO would be, or even whether he wants the position.”

A publicly visible succession pipeline has never been established at Nvidia. For years, Huang has run the business with a flat organisational structure, 60 direct reports and no clearly identified second-in-command. A more pointed criticism came from Bernstein’s analyst: “How can you have the world’s most valuable company without any succession plan, or even anyone being groomed as a successor?”

Instead of trying to bridge that information gap, Morgan Stanley explicitly recognises the limits of its knowledge and incorporates them into the valuation as risk. The approach mirrors its willingness to “err on the side of caution” when forecasting revenue. Where uncertainty resists quantification, using conservative assumptions is itself a way of pricing it.


What Underpins Morgan Stanley’s “Overweight” Call?

Taken together, these arguments explain why Morgan Stanley has retained “Overweight”. In its view, the approximately 10% forecast cut already makes adequate allowance for the revenue effect of tighter export controls. It also considers concerns about CUDA’s competitive moat overstated and sees no damage to market share stability from the CEO transition. With the supply chain and product pipeline secured for the next 12 to 24 months, near-term delivery does not hinge on Huang’s personal relationships. Finally, while the prevailing share price accounts for a “major setback”, it does not reflect the scope for recovery after the interim arrangement gives way to a permanent CEO. At $267, the target indicates approximately 61% upside, based on easing uncertainty rather than a fresh acceleration in growth.

Yet the timing and identity of a permanent CEO remain unanswered in Morgan Stanley’s analysis. The bank concedes that Ian Buck’s strategic vision is unknown to it and provides no estimate for when succession will be settled. As a result, the main catalyst for the “receding uncertainty” trade has no defined timeline. “Overweight” communicates the bank’s directional stance, while the absence of a “Top Pick” designation conveys no urgency. Read together, the decision to remove Nvidia from its Top Picks list on November 11 and the November 13 decision to retain “Overweight” while lowering the price target send a consistent message: Morgan Stanley is still positive on the outlook, but does not regard this as the time to concentrate its bets.

Attention now turns to Nvidia’s FY27 third-quarter results, due after the market closes on November 18, and the earnings call that Kress will host as interim CEO. Market expectations stand at approximately $109 billion in quarterly revenue and around 90% year-over-year earnings growth. The reported figures are unlikely to disappoint. More important for investors than revenue and profit will be what Kress says about progress in the search for a permanent CEO, alongside management’s specific quantification of the impact of tighter export controls. Those two issues already sit at the centre of Morgan Stanley’s valuation framework. When Nvidia itself will answer them remains the outstanding question.