Morgan Stanley Views Nvidia’s “Post-Jensen Huang Era” as a Major Setback, Not a Structural Collapse

A $300 price target and an “Overweight” rating remained in place when Morgan Stanley took Nvidia off its semiconductor “Top Picks” list on 11 November. Jensen Huang formally stepped down as CEO two days afterwards. The bank subsequently revised its target to $267 in an updated report, characterising his departure as a “major setback” without changing its “Overweight” recommendation. Elsewhere on Wall Street, a recent Cailian Press tally records at least 10 leading analysts cutting Nvidia from “Buy” to “Hold.” Price targets have come down at Goldman Sachs, JPMorgan, RBC and other institutions; Bernstein halved its target from $400 to $200. Within this group, Morgan Stanley is one of the few institutions whose stance has not become bearish.

TMGM Analysis: Financial Market News, Economic Calendar & Market Insights


Morgan Stanley Holds “Overweight” Despite a “Major Setback”

The bank has chosen its language carefully. Its description of a “Major setback” recognises how materially Huang’s exit affects Nvidia. During the past decade, his leadership brought innovations in hardware, software, networking, computing and storage. Customers and investors had ready access to him, while fast decisions and proactive management of the supply chain characterised his approach. An earnings report cannot replace any of these assets.

By leaving “Overweight” in place, however, the bank distinguishes disruption at the top from a failure of the underlying business. The relevant question is what Nvidia requires from Huang during the next 12 to 24 months, rather than his importance in general. Morgan Stanley considers those immediate requirements modest. Prepayments have secured most orders covering the next 12 months; the supply chain and product pipeline are settled, the Vera Rubin platform is scaling up, and the specifications for Rubin Ultra are substantially complete. Nvidia therefore needs to carry out an agreed roadmap during this period, not devise a new strategic direction. Delivering that plan requires much less personal input from the founder than breaking new ground would. The bank’s decision to retain “Overweight” rests on this difference between Nvidia’s lower short-term reliance on Huang and its greater dependence on him over the longer term.


Morgan Stanley Cuts Forecasts as Export and Succession Risks Diverge

Approximately 10% was taken off each of Morgan Stanley’s FY28 and FY29 data centre revenue forecasts. The bank now projects $62.298 billion for FY28, against $69.02 billion previously, and $86.67 billion for FY29, down from $97.02 billion. Its estimate of FY28 non-GAAP earnings per share dropped to $13.37 from $15.01. Expected revenue growth for FY28 also came down, from 70% to 53.5%.

The explanation accompanying those revisions merits attention. As Morgan Stanley puts it: “We are confident that we have cut to an overly conservative number.” The company had previously guided to shipment growth of 70% and demand growth of 100%. Set against those figures, the bank says its new growth projection of 53.5% “leaves considerable room for flexibility, but given the uncertainty and multiple rounds of downgrades, we would rather err on the side of caution.”

Morgan Stanley identifies two reasons for the cuts, keeping their effects separate. Restrictions on exports do not depend on the change of CEO. In the United States, the bank observed bipartisan support for further tightening chip export restrictions on China, with momentum strengthening markedly in the week of the report’s publication. Uncertainty about succession, by contrast, arises directly from the leadership change. Rather than translating that uncertainty into “lower revenue.”, the bank accounts for it by increasing the discount rate in its model. The move from a $300 target to $267 thus represents a reduced valuation multiple on the same projected cash flows, not a fall in the cash flows themselves.

Although they emerged during the same period, these developments work through different channels. Export restrictions bring down the absolute amount of revenue; uncertainty over succession raises the price paid for it. Both feature in Morgan Stanley’s model, but not as equivalent risks. Export controls pose a tangible downside that can be quantified. Succession presents uncertainty based on probabilities, which the passage of time can resolve.


Morgan Stanley Prices In the Cost of an “Interim CEO”

The appointment of CFO Colette Kress as interim CEO draws praise from Morgan Stanley, which describes her as: “An excellent CFO who can manage the transition effectively.” But the report moves straight from that endorsement to the practical constraint imposed by the “interim” label: “The interim designation could create challenges in securing customer commitments, arranging joint financing for major investments and obtaining approval for strategic plans.”

For the bank, the priority is clear: “Given the pace of AI development and the complexity of Nvidia’s planning, we believe appointing a permanent CEO as soon as possible should be a top priority.” This implies that leaving an interim CEO in place for an additional quarter prolongs friction costs in those three transaction categories by another quarter. The claim is not that “an interim CEO will cause revenue to decline,”. Instead, Morgan Stanley assigns a separate role in its pricing framework to “the duration of the interim arrangement”.

Among possible successors, Ian Buck, who heads the data centre business, is singled out by Morgan Stanley as “the internal candidate we hear mentioned most often,”. The bank also calls him “well known to customers, supply chain partners and some investors.” It then makes an unusually frank acknowledgement: “We have absolutely no idea what his strategic vision as CEO would be, or even whether he wants the position.”

There has never been a publicly visible succession pipeline at Nvidia. The flat management structure Huang has used for years comprises 60 direct reports, without an explicitly designated deputy. Bernstein’s analyst was more pointed: “How can you have the world’s most valuable company without any succession plan, or even anyone being groomed as a successor?”

Rather than supply answers it does not have, Morgan Stanley recognises the information shortfall and includes it as a valuation risk. That treatment is consistent with its decision to “err on the side of caution” in revenue projections. If uncertainty cannot be measured, adopting conservative assumptions is itself a means of assigning a price to it.


The “Overweight” Case Rests on Easing Uncertainty

Taken as a whole, the bank’s case for retaining “Overweight” has several elements. It regards the approximately 10% reduction in forecasts as sufficient to capture the revenue consequences of tighter export controls. It also judges fears about CUDA’s competitive moat excessive, while seeing no erosion of market share stability from the CEO change. With the supply chain and product pipeline secured over the next 12 to 24 months, near-term execution need not rely on Huang’s personal relationships. In addition, the prevailing share price allows for a “major setback” without recognising the potential recovery when a permanent CEO replaces the interim arrangement. The approximately 61% upside implied by the $267 target therefore depends on uncertainty diminishing, rather than growth accelerating again.

Neither the identity of the permanent CEO nor the date of the appointment is resolved by Morgan Stanley’s analysis. The bank admits it does not know Ian Buck’s strategic vision and supplies no succession timetable. There is consequently no timeline for the central catalyst in the “receding uncertainty” trade. An “Overweight” recommendation indicates a positive direction, but withholding a “Top Pick” designation suggests no urgency. The two decisions, taking Nvidia off the Top Picks list on 11 November and retaining “Overweight” with a lower target on 13 November, are consistent: Morgan Stanley remains constructive on the outlook without considering this the time to concentrate its bets.

Approximately $109 billion in quarterly revenue and around 90% year-on-year earnings growth are the market’s expectations for Nvidia’s FY27 third-quarter results, due after the market closes on 18 November. Kress will lead the earnings call in her capacity as interim CEO. The reported figures are unlikely to disappoint. Revenue and profit, however, are not the main points investors need to hear. More important are Kress’s update on the search for a permanent CEO and management’s specific quantification of tighter export controls. Those two issues already occupy a central place in Morgan Stanley’s valuation framework. Nvidia now faces the outstanding question of when it will supply its own answers.