Article

Overtrading Carries Hidden Costs: Recognise the Warning Signs and Learn How to Stop It

There is no fixed number of trades that defines overtrading. It occurs when you trade more frequently, or take larger positions, than your trading plan permits, eroding your account through additional costs and poorer-quality trades. Without a set threshold, many traders fail to recognise the habit until losses and costs mount.

Overtrading: The Main Points

  • Your trading plan determines whether trade frequency or position size amounts to overtrading, rather than a universal number of trades that applies to everyone.
  • Spreads and any commissions apply to each additional trade: at an illustrative $5 per trade, 10 trades a day cost $1,050 a month.
  • Reviewing the last 30 trades in your journal can identify overtrading if trades labelled C, which have no setup, produce an average loss.
  • Pre-session rules help curb overtrading, principally a cap on daily trades, a daily loss ceiling and a cooling-off period.

Overtrading Exceeds What Your Trading Plan Supports

When the number or size of your trades exceeds what your trading plan supports, you are overtrading. Also called excessive trading, this behaviour is generally emotion-led, with trades lacking a valid setup.

A daily total of 15 trades might suit one trader but be excessive for another. There is no fixed threshold: your own plan and trading style provide the benchmark for overtrading.

Two broad forms of overtrading can be distinguished.

  • Excessive trade frequency occurs when you place more trades than the setups in your plan generate, often using quick, small trades simply to remain occupied.
  • Excessive position sizing occurs when positions exceed the size permitted by your risk rules, often in an attempt to recover a loss through one trade.

Two further meanings sit outside this definition. A broker who trades a client's account excessively to generate commissions is engaging in broker churning. A business that expands faster than its cash resources is overtrading in the corporate sense, as discussed in the FAQs. For individual traders, several recognisable patterns emerge.

Overtrading Appears in Several Distinct Forms

Five common forms of overtrading fall within the trader's control. A further form, broker churning, involves a broker trading a client's account excessively. Use the table to identify the pattern that fits your trading and the rule absent from your plan.

CategoryHow It AppearsTypical Cause
Excessive trade frequencyFrequent trades, usually small and short-livedBoredom and keeping the trading screen open
Excessive position sizingPosition sizes that breach your risk rulesAn attempt to recover a loss rapidly
Discretionary overtradingAdjusting rules and size by instinctAn absence of firm position-sizing rules
Technical overtradingSelecting indicators to support a trade you have already decided to takeConfirmation bias
Shotgun overtradingOpening numerous small, unplanned positions simultaneouslyA desire for activity
Broker churningExcessive trading of a client's account by a brokerGenerating commission income

The reverse problem is undertrading: fear following a loss causes a trader to pass over valid setups. Among the forms of overtrading a trader can control, the underlying cause is always an emotion or an absent rule. These are the starting points for understanding why it happens.

Emotions and Missing Rules Drive Overtrading

An absent or disregarded trading plan, coupled with emotional decision-making, accounts for most overtrading. Its psychology centres on how fear, greed, boredom and overconfidence can prompt unnecessary trades or positions that exceed risk limits.

  • The desire to recover a loss can trigger revenge trading, a cause of overtrading in which both trade frequency and position size increase immediately after a losing trade.
  • Fear of missing out, or FOMO, draws traders towards moves already under way, while concern about finishing the day at a loss encourages late trades.
  • Excess confidence following consecutive wins can encourage larger positions and less convincing setups, as traders interpret recent success as evidence of skill.
  • Feeling bored or needing to remain occupied can make a quiet market seem like a trading opportunity, despite the absence of a setup.
  • The absence of a written trading plan allows mood to dictate decisions, with no rule defining when a trade must be avoided.
  • Game-like trading platforms can reinforce the impulse: notifications and one-tap orders make placing another trade quick and straightforward.
  • Switching to shorter timeframes produces more signals each hour, which can seem to offer more reasons to enter trades.

A repeating cycle often develops. After a loss, the desire to recover the money prompts larger or more frequent trades. Higher costs and further losses follow, restarting the cycle.

Overtrading cycle diagram showing a loop of four steps: loss, urge to win it back, more or bigger trades, then higher costs and losses

Recognising these causes as they arise can be difficult. The observable signs in your trading provide a more accessible starting point.

Rising Trade Counts and Weaker Reasons Signal Overtrading

When trade frequency increases but the justification for each entry becomes less convincing, overtrading is the clearest explanation. Look for the following warning signs in your own activity.

  • Exceeding the trade frequency permitted by your plan provides the most direct indication.
  • Being unable to identify the setup when entering a trade suggests an impulse, rather than a rule, drove the decision.
  • Increasing trade frequency immediately after losing suggests revenge trading.
  • Continuing beyond your scheduled trading hours, including late at night, leaves the session without a genuine end.
  • Gradual increases in position size across a week or month indicate overtrading through excessive sizing.
  • Adjusting or deleting your stop loss to leave a losing position open breaches the exit rule set out in your plan.
  • Searching a shorter timeframe for something to trade turns the chart into a source of justifications rather than valid setups.
  • Spending the day watching charts and becoming anxious without an open position indicates a trading habit that you struggle to switch off.
  • Seeing trading charges absorb a growing proportion of profits provides a financial indication that trade frequency is excessive.
  • Neglecting your trading journal because logging so many trades feels impractical removes the evidence that could reveal the issue.

Checklist of 10 signs of overtrading, including more trades than planned, trading after a loss, moving stops and skipping the trading journal

Until records support them, warning signs remain impressions. Reviewing your trading journal supplies that evidence.

A Journal Review Reveals Excess Trading

To establish whether you are overtrading, classify at least your last 30 trades in your journal, then assess the results for each category.

  1. Assign A to trades meeting the full setup in your plan, B to those meeting only part of it, and C to trades without a setup.
  2. For every entry, record the total number of trades placed that day.
  3. Assess the average outcome for A, B and C trades before comparing days with fewer trades against those with more.

You are overtrading if the average C trade loses money or if your highest-activity days deliver your poorest results. The loss-making category indicates which rule needs adding.

LabelDefinitionAction When the Category Makes an Average Loss
AA setup that fully meets your trading planReassess the plan rather than the number of trades
BAn incomplete setup that fails some rulesMake the checklist stricter to exclude B trades
CAn entry without a setup, prompted by boredom, FOMO or a preceding lossExclude C trades and introduce a daily trade cap or cooling-off period

Having identified the additional trades in your journal, you can turn to their financial cost.

Overtrading Raises Costs and Deepens Trading Losses

In 2018, EU markets regulator ESMA found that between 74% and 89% of retail CFD accounts lose money. That leaves most traders little capacity for unnecessary charges or weak entries. Overtrading compounds the problem by increasing costs, reducing trade quality, raising the likelihood of substantial losses and exhausting the trader.

Additional Trades Accumulate Additional Costs

A winning trade and a losing trade both incur the spread and any commission. Costs therefore increase in direct proportion to trade frequency, unlike your edge. The difference between the buying and selling prices is the spread; commission is a per-trade fee charged on some accounts. Edge refers to the average profit per trade that your strategy generates across many trades. Holding positions overnight also incurs swap, which is an overnight financing charge.

For the monthly figures below, the assumptions are a rounded $5 cost for each trade and 21 trading days per month. These figures are illustrative only: actual charges vary with the instrument, account type and market.

Daily Trade CountIllustrative Cost for Each TradeNumber of Trading DaysTotal Monthly Cost
1$521$105
5$521$525
10$521$1,050
20$521$2,100

Bar chart of monthly trading costs at $5 per trade over 21 days: $105 for 1 trade a day, $525 for 5, $1,050 for 10 and $2,100 for 20

Once charges are deducted, a trade offering little or no edge becomes loss-making. The example shows a planned A setup retaining a profit after costs, a weak B setup reaching breakeven and a C trade prompted by boredom making a loss.

Trade CategoryExpected Outcome Before ChargesTrading ChargeExpected Outcome After Charges
A setup taken according to plan+$25$5+$20
B setup with weak justification+$5$5$0
C trade prompted by boredom$0$5−$5

Evidence from equity investors supports the same conclusion. In research published in The Journal of Finance in 2000, Brad Barber and Terrance Odean examined 66,465 US households over 1991 to 1996. After costs, the most active households achieved annual returns of 11.4%, against a market return of 17.9%. The authors associated that shortfall with trading frequency and costs.

Although charges are the readily visible cost of overtrading, the trades themselves usually account for the larger loss.

Weaker Setups Reduce Quality and Increase Losses

Additional trades typically involve less convincing setups and less careful consideration, reducing the average outcome per trade. This is how overtrading erodes trade quality. Following a loss with larger or repeated trades increases the drawdown, meaning the decline from the account's highest value to its lowest. When using leverage, multiple open positions consume more margin, potentially lowering the margin level towards a margin call, the broker's warning that available margin in the account is running low.

The damage is not confined to the account: overtrading also takes a toll on the trader.

Constant Trading Creates Stress and Burnout

Long periods at the screen and continual decision-making cause decision fatigue, leaving less attention for each subsequent choice. Overtrading therefore brings stress and burnout. As tired traders take poorer trades, further losses and stress follow. If trading begins to feel compulsive or difficult to stop, consulting a qualified professional is a sensible course.

These pressures make it important to distinguish active trading from overtrading.

Daily Trade Counts Alone Do Not Define Overtrading

Your tested strategy, trading plan and style determine the limit, not a universal daily total. Trades beyond those generated by that strategy constitute overtrading. Treat the ranges below as examples commonly cited by traders, rather than rules.

Style of TradingFrequently Cited RangePoint at Which Trading Becomes Excessive
Scalping10 or more daily tradesEntering outside planned setups or hours, or allowing costs to absorb most profits
Day tradingApproximately 1 to 5 daily tradesPlacing extra trades following losses or without a setup that meets the plan
Swing tradingA few weekly tradesUsing shorter-timeframe charts to enter trades each day

Use your journal to calculate the average daily number of valid A setups as a practical basis for your own limit. Where the plan generates two A setups on a typical day, taking a third or fourth trade requires clear justification. Numerous daily trades need not amount to overtrading for scalpers, provided every entry complies with the plan.

Establishing a limit comes first; firm rules then help make observing it habitual.

Pre-Set Rules Help Bring Overtrading Under Control

Before the session begins, establish rules and commit to keeping them fixed. This replaces numerous weak trades with fewer, higher-quality entries. The following seven steps each introduce a rule that reduces, but does not eliminate, risk.

Step 1: Define Valid Entries in a Written Trading Plan

Specify the markets and timeframe you use, together with the precise requirements for a valid setup, in a written plan. For every setup, state the stop-loss placement and profit target. Reject any trade that fails to meet the plan, and review the plan against your journal weekly.

Step 2: Check Every Order Against a Pre-Trade List

Before submitting an order, complete a brief pre-trade checklist. Any negative answer means passing on the trade.

  • Does the entry meet my setup requirements?
  • Have I placed my stop loss?
  • Does the position size comply with my rule?
  • Have I remained below my daily trade cap?

Step 3: Cap the Number of Trades Each Day

Base your daily cap on the average number of valid A setups recorded each day in your journal. Once the cap is reached, close the platform. Although this occasionally means passing up a good setup, missing one worthwhile trade usually costs much less than forcing ten entries. That makes the trade-off worthwhile.

Step 4: Limit the Loss You Accept Each Day

Before trading starts, choose a small proportion of your account as the maximum acceptable daily loss. Reaching that limit ends the trading day, regardless of subsequent chart movements. While the rule limits a poor day's losses, a price gap past your stop loss can still cause the loss to exceed the ceiling.

Step 5: Determine Position Size Before Entering

Apply a fixed rule to your position size before entering, such as the 1 to 2% rule, to prevent size increasing in pursuit of lost money. Under the 1 to 2% rule, only a small proportion of the account is put at risk per trade. It is a common guideline, not a guarantee. To calculate the size for an individual trade, you can use TMGM's position size calculator.

Step 6: Restrict Trading to Scheduled Hours

Choose trading hours that coincide with your strategy's strongest performance and avoid the platform at other times. A fixed schedule reduces boredom-driven entries during lunch breaks or late at night. Persistent overtrading on short-term charts may be addressed by moving to a higher timeframe, where fewer signals allow more time for consideration.

Step 7: Pause After Losses or a Substantial Win

Allow a fixed cooling-off period before your next entry following a loss, two consecutive losses or a substantial win. The pause gives the desire to recover money, or the excitement of winning, time to subside before another decision. During this break, also disable price alerts that are not essential.

Overtrading: Answers to Common Questions

Overtrading Your Own Account Is Not Illegal

Trading your own account excessively is not illegal; the harm is confined to your account. The position differs for broker churning, where a broker trades a client's account excessively to generate commissions. In many markets, financial regulators regard this practice as misconduct.

Scalping Does Not Necessarily Mean Overtrading

The two are distinct. Scalping deliberately involves numerous small trades within a planned strategy, with each entry governed by defined rules. It crosses into overtrading when the scalper disregards planned setups or hours, increases trading after losses, or overlooks the effect of spreads and commissions on small profits.

Revenge Trading Is One Driver of Overtrading

The broader term, overtrading, describes trade numbers or sizes that exceed what a plan supports. Revenge trading is a particular cause: following a loss, the trader tries to recover money quickly through larger or more frequent trades. Boredom, FOMO and overconfidence can also produce overtrading, so its scope extends beyond revenge trading.

Feature ComparedOvertradingRevenge Trading
DefinitionTrade frequency or size exceeding what the plan supportsTrading with the aim of rapidly recovering a loss
Underlying promptLosing trades, boredom, FOMO or excessive confidenceA loss just incurred
Usual behaviourFrequent entries and less convincing setupsIncreased size, rule breaches and deletion of the stop loss
Primary remedyA trading plan and daily cap on tradesA daily loss ceiling and cooling-off period

Consecutive Wins Can Also Lead to Overtrading

Overtrading can follow a winning streak as well as losses. Successive wins may foster overconfidence, encouraging entries with weaker setups or position sizes beyond the plan's limits. Pausing after a substantial win allows that confidence to settle before trading again.

Business Overtrading Occurs When Growth Outruns Cash

For a business, overtrading describes sales growth that exceeds the support available from cash and working capital. Even with apparently strong sales, the company lacks sufficient cash to pay staff and suppliers. This guide instead addresses trading, where overtrading means taking trades in greater numbers or sizes than the plan supports.

A group of expert analyst with strengths in fundamental and technical analysis, and years of experience in the Global Equity Markets, Forex, Precious Metals, Oils and other commodities, as well as Crypto, and so on.